According to NHTSA's data, Tesla's Cybercabs were involved in 8 crashes just two months into launching in Austin, Texas. But if you account for all robotaxis that use Level 4 ADAS, the number of incidents rises to 43 just this month. And the data shows an interesting trend.
NHTSA puts these incidents into two separate categories. One involves only vehicles using Tesla's Level 4 Automated Driving System where there's no driver, while the other contains Level 2 supervised ADAS-related crashes.
One key takeaway is that most of the crashes from the first list are minor, and two of them weren't Tesla's fault. In fact, in many of the incidents, the robotaxis didn't go beyond 5 mph during the incident. These vehicles tend to drive over large potholes or bump other cars in a parking lot. However, one report in September describes a scary scenario in which the vehicle drove over a raised concrete edge of a parking lot across a sidewalk and down a curb at a very low speed with a rider on board.
You might be thinking that this is good news for Tesla, but in actuality, the data is biased. The robotaxi service is concentrated in dense urban areas, and these vehicles rarely drive on a highway. They operate in geofenced zones, so it's normal not to see fatal crashes with Tesla's self-driving software.
That's where the second list with Level 2 data comes into play. When the speed cap is removed and the same software starts driving on highways, even though there's a driver behind the wheel, crashes can be fatal. NHTSA data shows 69 fatal crashes, 52 of which had a median speed of 53 mph, and 29 of all 69 happened at speeds above 50 mph.
One important caveat with this data is that these reports do not explicitly say Tesla's software was at fault, but the ADAS was engaged within 30 seconds prior to each crash.
These two datasets show that Tesla's software has a speed problem. It's fairly safe in urban environments and causes mostly property damage, but it will regularly engage in high-speed, highway traffic incidents, many of which are dangerous or even fatal.
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
RSS
Settings
Log in I forgot my password Sign up